Farscape Reviews

Return to season list

Farscape - Season 3 - Episode 17

Farscape - 3x17 - The Choice - Originally Aired: 2001-8-17

My Rating - 4

Fan Rating Average - 5.31

Rate episode?

Rating: 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
# Votes: 35 5 8 5 2 5 6 7 7 52 5

Grieving for Crichton, Aeryn travels to a planet of mystics and frauds and makes contact with a man who claims to be Talyn Lyzcak, her father. Talyn puts her in touch with Seer Cresus, a creature who is able to 'channel' the dead Crichton. Meanwhile, Stark and Rygel search for Aeryn, but first come across an old enemy. Lurking on the planet with malign, warped designs of her own is Aeryn's mother, Xhalax Sun. [DVD]

Filler Quotient: 0, not filler, do not skip this episode.
- Numerous major long term plot threads are serviced here.


- Virginia Hey lent her voice to reprise her role as Zhaan to play Zhaan's voice in Stark's head.
- This is the first episode in which one of the Crichtons doesn't appear; a non-imagined one anyway.
- As of this episode Aeryn has become aware of the erased timeline from The Locket in some capacity.

Remarkable Scenes
- The alien Aeryn hired claiming to be her father.
- Rygel: "It's a planet of Starks down here!"
- Stark catching a glimpse of Aeryn's mother.
- Stark attacking Crais for not killing Xhalax.
- Rygel flying up to Aeryn's room.
- Aeryn: "I returned from the dead. Why can't he?"
- Xhalax barging into Aeryn's room and killing "Talyn."
- Xhalax revealing that she killed Aeryn's (real) father so that Aeryn could live.
- Crais barging into Aeryn's room and finally killing Xhalax.
- Stark departing Talyn and staying on the planet.

My Review
This episode is overwrought. Unkilling Xhalax just to kill her again after Aeryn's already suffered the loss of Crichton was a lame attempt to prolong the drama that was better executed in Relativity, climaxing in Infinite Possibilities. As a consequence, this episode was largely redundant and spending an entire episode watching Aeryn grieve in this bizarre, brooding way adds little value to the overall story, arguably diminishing it. Combine that with the random clip show including clips from the erased timeline of The Locket of all episodes and we've got the makings of a real flop.

However the episode redeemed itself somewhat toward the end with a few interesting tidbits of plot such as the curious departure of Stark who goes on some kind of spiritual journey to reach Zhaan and especially the plot point of Talyn supposedly locating Moya. Xhalax' death was also about as well played as it could have been given the dismal premise of the episode. It's nice to see Crais finally do what he should have done in the first place and even better was seeing signs that Xhalax had finally started to see the error of her ways in the seconds just prior to her death. So for all that the premise was terrible, the episode did a halfway decent job of overcoming that.

The following are comments submitted by my readers.

  • From Hugo on 2016-02-16 at 9:54pm:
    Nice to see Aeryn with her hair out, and a dress for a change - and good work by Claudia Black. I found the story a tad too slow without not much development - and the whole Xhalax track felt odd.

    Amazing alien makeup in "Talyn" and Cresus.
  • From Margaret J on 2019-07-17 at 11:37pm:
    IMO they managed to portray someone in deep grief, their actions,feelings and thoughts all fairly accurately. So as a character piece for Aeryn it is very well done
    Xhalax poping up just did not work for me. Her motivations were all over the place and her character makes no sense first she breaks the rules and has Aeryn out of love, goes to se her and tells her this as a child, than years later shows hatred and blame towards her,than hates her even more plans an elaborate scam just to hurt her, than acts like she cared all along - To me the story made about equal sense. The planning of it all must have been difficult. She and fake Talyn were obviously there for a while being that others on the planet knew her so well. How did she know when and if John would die, that Aeryn would be grieving and go to that planet seeking communication. The whole thing hurts my head thinking about it.
    As for stark it just seems like his leaving the crew and staying on the planet came out of the blue, no real prior signs that he wished to leave, or even that he was searching for Zahn. I just feel that if they were planing this they should have built it up a bit.
    So even though I enjoyed the episode quite a bit due to the above issues I only rated it a seven (7)

Prove to me that you are a real person and not a spam robot by typing in the text of this image:

Return to season list